resumed the pleasant task of proposing the problem of the week. The one we have today is actually the last to put the past year apprentices:
look at the two rectangles in Fig. Which of the two takes up more surface area, the ABCD or the BEFD? Explain your answer.
Of course, do not wait for our beloved public, the answer to the problem is below the illustration.
[This photograph mathematics is taken from the web's will . For now, I do not know where the photo was taken, but I would like to find out, is a good collection of cuboids in it, with their corresponding rectangles that the prospect has become simple parallelograms]
Solution:
First, if you look carefully at the figure, one might argue that ABCD is a rectangle, but BEFD not, because their angles are not straight. The chart did with the Windows Paint program or similar program, and in fact, I went to BEFD angles as straight as intended. But this detail has no bearing on the problem. Or we can draw correctly for BEFD is a rectangle, or we can assume that is a rectangle, or we can completely ignore the graphics, in any case the solution will be the same: surface ABCD is the same as BEFD .
The reasoning is simple: Both boxes have a triangle in common, the BCD. Then we need only prove that the remains of each area are equal, ie the area ABD is equal to the sum of the areas BEC + DCF.
This is easy, just draw a segment parallel to BE at point C to cut the segment BD at point G, as shown in the figure below:
BECG You can see that is a parallelogram, and therefore, because of parallel sides, the triangle equals the triangle BEC BCG. Similarly, GCFD is another parallelogram, and the triangles are equal GCD and DCF. So DCF = BEC + BCG + GCD, but the latter sum is equal to the triangle BCD.
Since ABCD is a rectangle, triangles BCD and ABD are equal, and hence we conclude that we needed to show: ABD = BEC + DCF.
Notes:
1) Geometrical reasoning that we used is a logical process that is being used in the geometry from the time of Euclid. Is independent of the measures of the sides, not connected with any algebraic operation, uses only geometric properties such as parallelism and similarity of triangles. Today is not usually teach this kind of reasoning to apprentices, and it is very difficult for them, motu proprio , what used to solve the problem. In fact, apprentices solved the problem by measuring the sides of the rectangles on the sheet where they were printed. Since the measures are never going to be accurate by the imperfections of the design and lack of precision of the rules used to measure the areas of rectangles leaving them different, and that's the answer I got. Not one of the apprentices found the correct answer.
2) I had a language problem in saying area, because I had entered the doubt that has been accepted recently that the area as area is a feminine noun. Thanks to the Royal English Academy I resolved: it has to say area, but with the indefinite article a , a normal ie area, but is not incorrect to say an area .
3) As has been several months since I proposed this problem and have been transferred to another vessel School, can not remember where I got it, but I think it was a textbook publisher Anaya.
0 comments:
Post a Comment